Best substrate for a planted tank: aquasoil vs Flourite vs Eco-Complete
Which substrate is best for a planted aquarium? Compare aquasoil, Seachem Flourite and CaribSea Eco-Complete by nutrients, pH effect, grain size and setup.
Short answer: The best substrate for a planted tank depends on how much work you want the substrate to do. If you want a nutrient-rich soil that softens water for plants and shrimp, choose an aquasoil such as CaribSea Samurai Soil or Seachem Aquavitro Aquasolum. If you want a substrate that lasts the life of the tank and won't change your pH, choose a clay gravel like Seachem Flourite or Flourite Black Sand. If you want a mineral-rich volcanic gravel that comes packed with live bacteria and needs no rinsing, choose CaribSea Eco-Complete Planted Black. Whatever you pick, root-feeding plants still benefit from root tabs over time.
The three kinds of planted tank substrate
Planted tank substrates fall into three groups, and most forum debates about "Flourite vs Eco-Complete vs aquasoil" come down to which group suits your tank:
- Aquasoils are granulated soils made for plants and shrimp. They soften water and help roots grow, but they are lighter and need some care during the first weeks.
- Porous clay gravels and sands such as Flourite are stable, do not break down, and do not change pH. Nutrients come from liquid fertilizer and root tabs.
- Mineral-rich volcanic gravels such as Eco-Complete sit between the two: they carry minerals and iron for roots and arrive with live bacteria to help a new tank cycle.
Quick comparison
| Substrate | Type | Effect on water | Grain | Rinse first? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CaribSea Samurai Soil | Aquasoil | Softens water for plants and shrimp | About 1 mm, uniformly graded | No; fill slowly over a plate |
| Seachem Aquavitro Aquasolum | Humate soil | Helps lower pH in alkaline water | Lightweight, porous | Lightly, if desired |
| Seachem Flourite | Porous clay gravel | Will not alter pH | Gravel | Yes, to remove dust |
| Seachem Flourite Black Sand | Porous clay sand | Will not alter pH | Fine black sand | Yes, to remove dust |
| Seachem Onyx Sand | Carbonate-rich sand | May raise pH 0.1–0.5 units; supports KH | Dark gray sand | Yes, to remove dust |
| CaribSea Eco-Complete Black | Volcanic basalt gravel | Rich in iron and minerals | 0.25–7.0 mm | No |
| CaribSea Eco-Complete Red | Laterite-based gravel | Rich in iron | 3.0–6.0 mm | No |
Grain sizes and pH notes come from CaribSea's and Seachem's own product pages.
Best for shrimp and soft-water plants: aquasoil
CaribSea Samurai Soil is CaribSea's substrate for shrimp and planted aquariums. CaribSea says its uniformly graded grains, about 1 mm in size, fit the pH and mineral requirements of the most sensitive freshwater fauna and flora, without the muddy texture and crumbling often seen with other brands. It is a nutrient-rich granulated soil that encourages root growth and softens water. Add it to the empty tank 2–3 inches deep, fill slowly over a plate, and change water frequently during the first weeks.
Seachem Aquavitro Aquasolum is a lightweight, porous substrate made from humic substances and minerals for planted aquariums and shrimp nano tanks. It helps lower the pH of alkaline water, and its black color shows off plants and livestock. Rinse lightly if you like, spread it 1–3 inches deep and fill the tank slowly over a plate or bag so you don't disturb the bed.
Choose aquasoil if you keep shrimp, soft-water plants or fish that prefer softer water. If you want to understand pH before you choose, read how to lower pH in an aquarium.
Best long-lasting, pH-neutral option: Seachem Flourite
Seachem describes Flourite as a specially fracted, stable porous clay gravel for the natural planted aquarium. It works best alone as the whole substrate bed but can be mixed with other gravels, and laterite or other gravel modifiers are not necessary. It is not chemically coated, will not alter pH, and is good for the life of the aquarium, so you never need to replace it. Seachem also says Flourite works with an undergravel filter and will not soften or break down.
For small foreground plants and carpets, Flourite Black Sand gives you the same clay material in a fine black grain. If your tap water is very soft and you want a little buffering, Seachem Onyx Sand is a dark gray, carbonate-rich sand that Seachem says supports optimal KH in freshwater planted tanks and may raise pH by 0.1–0.5 units depending on your source water.
Flourite does not come loaded with nutrients. Seachem says root tabs, liquid fertilizer and iron supplements "can be useful and helpful, but are not necessities," depending on how dense you want growth. See our guide to fertilizing a planted aquarium.
Best mineral-rich gravel with live bacteria: CaribSea Eco-Complete
CaribSea says Eco-Complete Planted Black (now also sold as Eco-Planted) has a basaltic volcanic base containing iron, calcium, magnesium, potassium, sulfur and over 25 other elements to nourish aquatic plants. The grains are highly porous, there are no dyes, paints or coatings, and each bag contains live heterotrophic bacteria that turn fish waste into plant food, which CaribSea says makes cycling a new aquarium faster and safer. CaribSea's catalog adds that iron-rich Eco-Complete eliminates the need for laterite.
Eco-Complete Red is laterite-based and, according to CaribSea, an excellent choice if your planted tank includes soft-bellied, bottom-dwelling fish. Both colors need no rinsing. Pour the substrate and its liquid into the empty tank to a depth of 2–3 inches, fill slowly and plant once the water clears.
CaribSea's FAQ says you can mix other substrates with Eco-Complete, but no more than 50%, and you should only put another substrate on top of it in a brand-new setup.
How deep should a planted tank substrate be?
The manufacturer and store directions for these substrates call for a bed about 2–3 inches deep (1–3 inches for Aquasolum). Whichever you choose:
- Rinse Flourite and Onyx before use to remove dust from shipping. Don't rinse Eco-Complete; pour it in with its liquid.
- Fill slowly. Seachem suggests placing a bowl in the tank and pouring water into the bowl so it overflows gently onto the bed.
- Expect some initial cloudiness. Filter floss clears it; see how to clear cloudy aquarium water.
- Cycle the tank before adding fish. Our cycling guide walks you through it.
Do I still need root tabs?
Root-feeding plants such as swords and crypts benefit from extra food at the roots, especially in a clay gravel like Flourite that does not come loaded with nutrients. Liquid Gardens Osmocote Root Tabs are slow-release tabs for root-feeding plants. Push them deep into the substrate near plant roots, several inches apart, and replace them every few months.
FAQ
Is Eco-Complete better than Flourite?
Neither is better for every tank. Eco-Complete comes with minerals, iron and live bacteria and needs no rinsing. Flourite is pH-neutral, lasts the life of the tank and is easy to mix with other gravels. Both benefit from fertilizer as the tank matures.
Can I use plain sand or gravel for plants?
Yes, many hobbyists do, but you'll rely more on root tabs and liquid fertilizer. Browse our full substrate collection for sands and gravels.
Which is best for a beginner?
If you want the least fuss, a substrate that won't change your water chemistry, such as Flourite, or one that needs no rinsing, such as Eco-Complete, is the easiest place to start. Setting up from scratch? Read setting up your first freshwater tank.
Shop all planted soils, sands and gravels in our Substrate collection, and find fertilizers and plant care in Live Plants & Plant Care.