How to choose fish food: flakes vs pellets vs wafers
How to pick the right aquarium fish food: flakes, floating or sinking pellets, wafers and treats, matched to where your fish eat and their mouth size.
Short answer: pick fish food by where your fish eat and how big their mouths are. Flakes and floating pellets suit surface and mid-water fish, sinking pellets reach fish lower down, and wafers are for bottom feeders like plecos, catfish and loaches. Choose a size that fits the smallest mouth in the tank. A mixed community tank usually needs two foods: one that floats and one that sinks. Feed only what your fish eat and remove leftovers.
Fish food types at a glance
| Type | Where it ends up | Best for | Examples we carry |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flakes | Floats, then slowly sinks | Small surface and mid-water fish | NutriDiet Tropical Flakes, NLS Optimum Flakes, NorthFin Community Flake |
| Floating pellets | Stays at the surface | Bettas, goldfish and other surface eaters | Hikari Betta Bio-Gold, Hikari Goldfish Staple |
| Sinking pellets | Mid-water to bottom | Community fish that feed below the surface | NLS Community Formula, NorthFin Community Formula |
| Wafers | Sinks fast and holds its shape | Plecos, catfish, loaches | Hikari Sinking Wafers, Hikari Algae Wafers, NorthFin Kelp Wafers |
| Freeze-dried treats | Floats, then soaks and sinks | Bettas, cichlids, community fish as a treat | Hikari Bio-Pure Freeze Dried Blood Worms |
| Seaweed sheets | Clipped to the glass | Tangs and other grazing marine fish, cichlids, goldfish | Two Little Fishies Sea Veggies |
Step 1: Watch where your fish eat
Watch a feeding. Fish that rush the surface do well with flakes or floating pellets. Fish that wait mid-water often take sinking pellets as they fall. Fish that stay on the bottom may never get food that's eaten up top, so they need something that sinks straight to them. Hikari's Sinking Wafers are made for exactly that: they sink fast and hold their shape so bottom feeders can graze.
Step 2: Match food size to mouth size
Small fish like tetras can't fit big pellets in their mouths, and big fish often ignore tiny crumbles. Many foods come in more than one size:
- NorthFin Community Formula: 0.5 mm and 1 mm pellets for small community fish.
- New Life Spectrum Community Formula: sinking pellets from 1 mm up to 10 mm, for freshwater and marine community fish.
- Hikari Algae Wafers: Mini and Regular wafers.
- Hikari Goldfish Staple: baby pellet size for small and young goldfish.
Step 3: Match the food to the fish
| Fish | Good starting foods |
|---|---|
| Community tropicals (tetras, rasboras, guppies) | NorthFin Community Formula, NutriDiet Tropical Flakes |
| Bettas | Hikari Betta Bio-Gold (floating, betta-sized), NutriDiet Betta Flakes |
| Goldfish | Hikari Goldfish Staple, NorthFin Goldfish Formula, NutriDiet Goldfish Flakes |
| Cichlids | Hikari Cichlid Gold, NorthFin Cichlid Formula |
| Plecos, otocinclus and other algae eaters | Hikari Algae Wafers, NorthFin Kelp Wafers |
| Corydoras, catfish, loaches | Hikari Sinking Wafers |
| Marine fish | NorthFin Marine Formula (1 and 2 mm), NutriDiet Marine Plus Flakes |
| Tangs and grazing marine fish | Sea Veggies seaweed sheets on a Sea Veggies clip, Saki-Hikari Marine Herbivore |
Common fish feeding mistakes
- Feeding only what floats. In a busy community tank, the fast surface fish can eat everything before slower or bottom-dwelling fish reach it. Add a sinking pellet or wafer.
- Using food that's too big. If fish spit food out or ignore it, try a smaller pellet size or a flake.
- Overfeeding. Extra food that sits on the bottom becomes waste. Feed a little, watch it get eaten, and add more only if it's all gone.
- Leaving wafers or seaweed in too long. Remove anything uneaten so it doesn't rot in the tank.
- Feeding only treats. Freeze-dried bloodworms are a treat. Keep a staple food as the main diet.
Freshwater vs saltwater foods
Many staples are labeled for one type of tank. NorthFin Marine Formula is made for saltwater fish, and Hikari Betta Bio-Gold and Goldfish Staple are for freshwater. Some foods, like Hikari Sinking Wafers, Algae Wafers and Bio-Pure Blood Worms, are listed for both freshwater and saltwater. Check the label before you buy.
How much and how often to feed
Follow the directions on your food's label. Hikari's labels, for example, say to feed small amounts and only what your fish will eat, and to remove uneaten food. Food left in the tank breaks down into waste, which fouls the water and raises nitrate. See how to lower nitrate. Small portions, watched until they're gone, are the safest habit.
Feeding while you're away
Seachem NutriDiet Vacation Tabs are time-release tablets that feed freshwater fish for up to 7 days. Use them as the label directs.
FAQ
Are flakes or pellets better?
Neither is better for every tank. Flakes are easy to spread for small surface and mid-water fish. Pellets give you more control over size and whether the food floats or sinks.
Do bottom feeders need their own food?
Usually, yes. If the fish above eat everything first, a sinking wafer or pellet makes sure bottom feeders get food.
Can I feed just one food?
One good staple can work in a single-species tank. Community tanks with fish at different levels usually need a floating food and a sinking food.
Feeding large carnivorous fish that won't eat at the top? Hikari Massivore Delite is an extra-large sinking pellet (about 1 inch) made for big carnivores.
For saltwater fish, New Life Spectrum Marine Fish Formula is a 1–1.5 mm sinking pellet made with whole Antarctic krill, herring, squid and algae-based ingredients.