Best goldfish food: sinking pellets vs flakes for fancy and common goldfish

Sinking or floating? Compare Hikari, NorthFin, NLS and Seachem goldfish foods for fancy and common goldfish, plus how much and how often to feed.

Short answer: For most goldfish, the best everyday food is a goldfish-specific sinking pellet sized to your fish's mouth, such as Hikari Sinking Goldfish Excel, NorthFin Goldfish Formula or New Life Spectrum Goldfish Formula. Sinking food is the safer choice for round-bodied fancy goldfish (orandas, ryukins, fantails, lionheads), because it lets them eat without gulping air at the surface. Slim-bodied common, comet and shubunkin goldfish can also eat a floating pellet like Hikari Goldfish Gold. Whatever you choose, feed small amounts and remove what isn't eaten within a few minutes.

Sinking vs floating goldfish food

This is the choice that matters most. Fancy goldfish have short, rounded bodies, and when they snatch food off the surface they can swallow air along with it. Hikari describes its Sinking Goldfish Excel as a sinking pellet that reduces air gulping at the surface, which is why it is a good fit for fancy goldfish prone to buoyancy problems.

Floating pellets and flakes are easy to watch, so you can see exactly how much your fish eat. They work well for single-tail goldfish that are strong swimmers. If you keep fancy and single-tail goldfish together, a sinking staple means the fancies are not forced to compete at the surface.

Goldfish foods compared

Food Type Pellet size Best for
Hikari Sinking Goldfish Excel Sinking pellet Baby pellet Fancy goldfish; color support
NorthFin Goldfish Formula Slow-sinking pellet 2 mm or 3 mm All types of goldfish; whole-ingredient diet
New Life Spectrum Goldfish Formula Sinking pellet 1 mm or 3 mm Goldfish of most sizes; natural color
Saki-Hikari Fancy Goldfish Color Enhancing Sinking pellet with probiotic Mini pellet Fancy goldfish; digestion and color
Hikari Lionhead Sinking pellet Mini pellet Lionhead, oranda, ranchu and other hooded breeds
Hikari Wheat-Germ Pellet Mini pellet Easy digestion; cooler water
Hikari Goldfish Gold Floating pellet See listing Color-enhancing daily food
Hikari Goldfish Staple Floating pellet Baby pellet Small and young goldfish
Seachem NutriDiet Goldfish Flakes Flake Flake Small goldfish; variety feeding

Best everyday sinking pellets

Hikari Sinking Goldfish Excel

Sinking Goldfish Excel is a balanced daily pellet in a baby pellet size, a good match for small and young goldfish. Hikari lists it alongside Goldfish Gold as one of its foods that offer color enhancement, using carotenes and carotenoids to bring out natural color.

NorthFin Goldfish Formula

NorthFin makes its Goldfish Formula as a slow-sinking omnivore pellet for all types of goldfish, in 2 mm and 3 mm sizes. NorthFin lists a guaranteed analysis of 36% protein (minimum), 5% fat (minimum) and 5% fiber (maximum). The first ingredient is organic kelp, followed by whole Antarctic krill meal, herring meal and sardine meal, with spirulina and garlic further down the list. NorthFin says its foods contain no fillers and no artificial colors. Choose the pellet size that fits your fish's mouth.

New Life Spectrum Goldfish Formula

NLS Goldfish Formula is a sinking pellet made with whole Antarctic krill, herring, squid and algae-based ingredients. It enhances color naturally without artificial hormones and is made to be highly digestible, which means less waste in the tank. It comes in Regular (1 mm) and Large (3 mm) pellets.

Foods for fancy goldfish and special needs

Saki-Hikari Fancy Goldfish

Hikari calls Saki-Hikari Fancy Goldfish the result of years of work finding probiotics that actually benefit the fish's immune system and digestion. It is rich in astaxanthin and cultured spirulina, plus vitamin E and stabilized vitamin C. It is a sinking mini pellet, and the live probiotic helps improve digestion and reduce waste.

Hikari Lionhead

Hikari designed its Lionhead diet for Lionhead, Oranda, Ranchu and other specific breeds. Hikari says it promotes growth of their trademark heads (the wen) without relying on live foods. It is a sinking mini pellet.

Hikari Wheat-Germ

Goldfish Wheat-Germ is Hikari's easy-to-digest option. Hikari says its high levels of wheat germ make it a good choice when goldfish have swim bladder issues and cannot swim upright, and it can also be fed to baby koi. It is also a good choice in cooler water.

Floating pellets and flakes

Hikari Goldfish Gold is a color-enhancing floating pellet for all goldfish varieties that brings out deep reds and oranges. Hikari Goldfish Staple is a floating daily pellet in a baby size, made for small and young goldfish. Seachem NutriDiet Goldfish Flakes are a high-protein flake diet fortified with garlic, chlorella and vitamin C. Flakes are useful for small goldfish whose mouths are too small for pellets and as one part of a varied diet.

How much and how often to feed goldfish

  • Feed small amounts 1–3 times a day, only what your goldfish eat within a few minutes. Always follow the directions on the label of the food you use.
  • Remove uneaten food. Sinking pellets can hide in gravel, so check the bottom after feeding.
  • Match pellet size to your fish. Smaller pellets (baby, mini, 1–2 mm) are easier for young or small goldfish; save 3 mm pellets for fish big enough to take them easily.
  • Rotate two foods, for example a sinking staple plus a color or specialty food, to give your fish some variety.

Goldfish are messy eaters, and leftover food breaks down into ammonia. Keep an eye on water quality with a test kit and regular water changes. Our guides on lowering ammonia, doing a water change and testing your water walk you through it.

Which goldfish food should you buy?

Browse every goldfish, tropical and cichlid food in our fish food collection, or shop the full Hikari range. New to fish food in general? Read how to choose fish food: flakes vs pellets vs wafers.