Best cichlid food: pellets for mbuna, peacocks, haps and oscars

Which cichlid food should you buy? Match the food to your cichlid's diet, then pick pellet size and floating or sinking. NorthFin, New Life Spectrum and Hikari compared.

Short answer: The best cichlid food is the one that matches what your cichlids eat in the wild. Carnivorous and omnivorous cichlids such as peacocks, haps and oscars do well on a krill- and fish-based pellet like NorthFin Cichlid Formula, New Life Spectrum Cichlid Formula or Hikari Cichlid Gold. Plant-eating cichlids such as mbuna and Tropheus need a vegetable-based staple like Hikari Cichlid Excel or NorthFin Veggie Formula. Then pick a pellet size your smallest fish can swallow and decide between floating and sinking.

Step 1: Is your cichlid a carnivore, omnivore or herbivore?

Hikari's own cichlid feeding advice starts here, and it is the most important choice you make. Hikari says most African cichlids are herbivores that live on algae, aquatic plants and biofilm. Carnivorous cichlids have very short intestines, so they need more animal protein (fish, insects and crustaceans) and usually do best with more frequent feedings. Omnivores, which Hikari says include angelfish and peacocks, eat both plant and animal matter.

  • Herbivores (mbuna, Tropheus and other algae grazers): choose a vegetable-rich staple with kelp, spirulina or wheat germ near the top of the ingredient list.
  • Omnivores (peacocks, angelfish, many Central Americans): a balanced cichlid pellet, with a veggie food in the rotation.
  • Carnivores (predatory cichlids that eat fish, insects and crustaceans): a high-protein pellet based on krill, herring or other seafood.

Not sure which group your fish belong to? Look up the species before you buy. If you keep a mixed tank, feed the staple that suits the most sensitive group and add the other food as a second option.

Best cichlid foods we stock, compared

Food Best for Floats or sinks Pellet sizes Key facts (from the maker)
NorthFin Cichlid Formula Carnivorous and omnivorous cichlids Slow sinking 1, 2 and 3 mm 42% protein min; whole Antarctic krill, herring and sardine meal first; no fillers; made in Canada
New Life Spectrum Cichlid Formula Small and medium cichlids Sinking 1–1.5 mm Whole Antarctic krill, herring, squid and algae-based ingredients; natural color enhancement without artificial hormones
Hikari Cichlid Gold All cichlids and larger tropicals, including oscars Floating Baby, Mini, Medium, Large Color-enhancing daily diet; 40% protein min (Mini, Medium and Large)
Hikari Sinking Cichlid Gold Cichlids that feed below the surface Sinking Mini, Medium Sinking version of the color-enhancing Cichlid Gold
Hikari Cichlid Excel Herbivorous cichlids such as mbuna Floating Mini (about 2.5–2.8 mm), Medium (about 4.5–4.8 mm) Wheat germ and spirulina; lower protein (35% min) for herbivores and omnivores
Hikari Sinking Cichlid Excel Herbivorous cichlids that feed low Sinking Mini (about 2.5–2.8 mm) Same vegetable-rich idea as Cichlid Excel in a sinking pellet
NorthFin Veggie Formula Herbivores and omnivores (NorthFin names mbuna, Tropheus and plecos) Slow sinking 1 and 3 mm Organic kelp is the first ingredient; 36% protein min; spirulina and garlic
Hikari Cichlid Bio-Gold+ Flowerhorn and similar cichlids Floating Mini, Medium Color-enhancing formula that supports growth and the nuchal hump

Best food for carnivorous and omnivorous cichlids

NorthFin Cichlid Formula is a slow-sinking pellet that NorthFin makes for all types of carnivorous and omnivorous cichlids. Its label lists whole Antarctic krill meal, whole herring meal and whole sardine meal as the first three ingredients, followed by wheat flour, organic kelp, spirulina, garlic and astaxanthin. NorthFin lists a 42% minimum protein and 5% minimum fat and says the food has no fillers. It comes in 1 mm, 2 mm and 3 mm pellets, so you can match it to juveniles or adult peacocks and haps.

New Life Spectrum Cichlid Formula is a small 1–1.5 mm sinking pellet for small and medium cichlids. It is made with whole Antarctic krill, herring, squid and algae-based ingredients, and New Life Spectrum says it enhances color naturally without artificial hormones. It comes in sizes from 80 g up to 2200 g, which suits fish rooms with many tanks.

Hikari Cichlid Gold is Hikari's color-enhancing daily diet for all types of cichlids and larger tropical fish, and Hikari says it is great for oscars too. It floats, and it comes in four pellet sizes: Baby (about 1.7–2.0 mm), Mini (about 3.2–3.7 mm), Medium (about 4.8–5.3 mm) and Large (about 7.2–8.2 mm). If your cichlids feed in the middle or bottom of the tank, choose Hikari Sinking Cichlid Gold, which comes in Mini and Medium pellets.

Best food for mbuna and other herbivorous cichlids

Hikari makes Cichlid Excel for herbivorous (plant-eating) fish. It combines wheat germ and spirulina with vitamins and minerals, and Hikari says it has the lower protein levels that herbivorous and omnivorous species need: 35% minimum, compared with 40% for Cichlid Gold Mini, Medium and Large. It floats. For mbuna that grab food on the way down or off the rocks, Hikari Sinking Cichlid Excel is the sinking version in a Mini pellet.

NorthFin Veggie Formula is the other good choice. Organic kelp is the first ingredient, ahead of krill and herring meal, and NorthFin names mbuna, Tropheus and plecos among the fish it is made for. It is slow sinking, has a 36% minimum protein and comes in 1 mm and 3 mm pellets.

Flowerhorns and other "hump" cichlids

Hikari Cichlid Bio-Gold+ is a floating color-enhancing pellet that supports growth and the nuchal hump in flowerhorns and similar cichlids. It comes in Mini and Medium pellets.

Choosing pellet size and floating vs sinking

  • Size: pick a pellet the smallest fish in the tank can swallow whole. In a mixed-size tank, a 1 mm or Mini pellet feeds everyone; larger fish simply eat more pellets.
  • Floating: it is easy to see how much was eaten and to net out leftovers. Hikari Cichlid Gold, Cichlid Excel and Bio-Gold+ float.
  • Sinking: it reaches fish that feed low or that are pushed off the surface by bolder tankmates. NorthFin pellets are slow sinking, New Life Spectrum Cichlid Formula sinks, and Hikari makes sinking versions of Cichlid Gold and Cichlid Excel.

How much and how often to feed cichlids

Hikari's directions for its cichlid foods are to feed two to three times a day only the amount your fish will completely eat in a few minutes, and to remove uneaten food after the feeding to avoid water quality problems. New Life Spectrum also says 2–3 times daily. Uneaten food fouls the water, so if pellets are still on the sand after a few minutes, feed less next time. See how to clear cloudy aquarium water and how to lower ammonia in a fish tank if you run into trouble, and keep up with regular water changes.

FAQ

Can I feed peacocks and mbuna the same food?

Many hobbyists keep them together. Because Hikari describes most African cichlids as herbivores, a vegetable-rich staple such as Hikari Cichlid Excel or NorthFin Veggie Formula is the safer base for a mixed tank, with an omnivore pellet such as NorthFin Cichlid Formula offered as a second food.

Should I rotate cichlid foods?

Offering two foods that suit your fish, for example a pellet and a veggie pellet, adds variety. Change foods gradually and watch that your fish accept the new one.

What about flakes?

NorthFin and Seachem both make cichlid flakes, and we carry them in the brand collections below. For more on food types, read how to choose fish food.

Shop the full ranges in our NorthFin, Hikari and New Life Spectrum collections. Setting up a new cichlid tank? Start with our first freshwater tank guide.