Best algae wafers for plecos and other bottom feeders
Hikari Algae Wafers, NLS AlgaeMAX, NorthFin Kelp Wafers and Vitalis Pleco Pellets compared, plus what to feed corydoras and loaches and how to feed a pleco after lights-out.
Short answer: For most plecos, the best everyday food is a sinking algae wafer fed after the lights go out. Good choices are Hikari Algae Wafers, New Life Spectrum AlgaeMAX Wafers and NorthFin Kelp Wafers. Add blanched vegetables a couple of times a week and keep driftwood in the tank. Corydoras and loaches eat differently and do better on small sinking wafers or pellets like Hikari Sinking Wafers. Whatever you feed, take out what's left over.
Why a pleco can't live on tank algae
Many people buy a pleco to "clean the tank" and never feed it. That starves a lot of plecos. NorthFin points out that in a river, a grazing pleco has a huge area of rock covered in algae and biofilm that grows back every day. A home aquarium has four glass panels and maybe a piece of wood, and a healthy bristlenose can clear that quickly. The algae in a lit tank can't grow back fast enough to feed a fish that grazes all the time.
So feed your pleco on purpose. Check what species you have first. NorthFin notes that the common and bristlenose plecos most people keep lean toward plant matter, while some fancy L-number plecos eat mostly meat. An algae wafer is the right staple for the first group but not enough on its own for the second.
Best algae wafers and pellets for plecos
These are the sinking foods we stock that are made for plecos and other grazing bottom feeders:
- Hikari Algae Wafers: Hikari says it developed these for plecos and other algae-eating bottom feeders. They have a raised disc shape that copies how plecos feed, and Hikari says they don't fall apart quickly in water. Hikari also says they're good for marine herbivores. We stock Mini and Regular wafers.
- New Life Spectrum AlgaeMAX Wafers: New Life Spectrum says AlgaeMAX contains nine kinds of aquatic vegetables, including seaweeds, kelp and spirulina, along with marine proteins like krill and squid. NLS says even herbivores need some of that protein to copy what they eat in the wild. Regular wafers are about 12 mm and Mini wafers about 7.5 mm.
- NorthFin Kelp Wafers: a 14 mm slow-sinking wafer. The first ingredient is organic kelp. NorthFin says they're for herbivorous and omnivorous fish, freshwater or saltwater, and recommends dropping them in after lights-out.
- Vitalis Pleco Pellets: 8 mm soft pellets that sink slowly and contain a blend of algae. Vitalis says they're made for grazing catfish such as plecos, bristlenose (Ancistrus), whiptails, hillstream loaches, Garra and Panaque. Fish can graze on them over time, so they also suit community tanks.
- NorthFin Veggie Formula: a plant-rich pellet in 1 mm and 3 mm sizes. NorthFin says it does the same job as Kelp Wafers for fish with smaller mouths.
Quick comparison
| Food | Form and size | Made for | Maker's feeding note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hikari Algae Wafers | Sinking disc, Mini or Regular | Plecos, other algae eaters, marine herbivores | Feed only what they finish within 2 hours. Feed late in the day or at night. |
| NLS AlgaeMAX Wafers | Sinking wafer, about 12 mm (Mini about 7.5 mm) | Herbivores, omnivores | Twice daily, only what they eat in about a minute. |
| NorthFin Kelp Wafers | Slow-sinking wafer, 14 mm | Herbivores, omnivores | Drop in after lights-out. |
| Vitalis Pleco Pellets | Soft slow-sinking pellet, 8 mm | Plecos and other grazing catfish | Feed in the evening when plecos are active. Remove uneaten food after a few hours. |
| Hikari Sinking Wafers | Soft disc, about 7 mm | Corydoras, loaches, small bottom feeders | Feed what they finish in 20 minutes. |
| Vitalis Catfish Pellets | Soft sinking pellet, 1 mm | Corydoras and other catfish | Small amounts once or twice daily. |
Feeding times differ a lot between brands because the foods are made differently. Always follow the label on the package you have.
Food for corydoras, loaches and other bottom feeders
Not every bottom feeder is a grazer. Hikari says its Sinking Wafers are a "soft disc" for bottom feeders with small mouths that face down and tend to gulp their food. The disc is smaller, made not to dissolve so night feeders get a chance to graze too, and Hikari says it won't cloud the water when fed as directed. Its main ingredients include marine and vegetable proteins. Hikari lists corydoras and loaches as the best fit.
Vitalis makes its Catfish Pellets soft and slow-sinking. They contain natural attractants that encourage catfish to forage. Vitalis lists corydoras, botia loaches, Synodontis and other catfish as the fish they're made for. In a community tank, put food in where the bottom feeders are so faster fish don't eat it all first.
If small midwater fish and small catfish share the same food, Hikari Micro Wafers are small, slowly sinking discs. Hikari lists them for small and medium tropical fish, especially tetras, livebearers, smaller cichlids and catfish, and says to feed what the fish finish in about a minute.
How to feed a pleco: step by step
- Wait until the lights go off. Hikari notes that many bottom feeders are nocturnal and do best fed late in the day or at night. NorthFin says feeding after lights-out also keeps the daytime fish from stealing the food.
- Drop food near its hiding spot. One wafer for an adult bristlenose-sized pleco is a sensible start. Adjust from there.
- Remove what's left. Hikari says to feed only what your fish finish within 2 hours for its Algae Wafers and to always remove uneaten food. Food left to rot adds ammonia and nitrate. If there's a wafer left in the morning, feed less.
- Add vegetables a couple of times a week. NorthFin suggests blanched zucchini, cucumber or a slice of sweet potato. Remove vegetable leftovers too.
- Give protein if your species needs it. Common and bristlenose plecos get some protein from AlgaeMAX or Kelp Wafers. Meat-eating L-number species need more. Look up your species before you settle on one food.
- Keep driftwood in the tank. NorthFin says bristlenose plecos rasp on wood and the fiber helps their digestion. It's not a full diet, so keep feeding wafers too.
FAQ
How many algae wafers should I feed my pleco?
Start with one wafer per adult pleco, after lights-out. If some is still there when the time on the label runs out, feed less next time. If your pleco's belly looks sunken, feed a little more.
Are algae wafers enough on their own?
They're a good staple for plant-eating plecos, but rotating in vegetables and a second food adds variety. Meat-eating plecos need more protein than an algae wafer gives them.
Can other fish eat algae wafers?
Yes. Hikari says its Algae Wafers suit other algae eaters, including marine herbivores. NLS and NorthFin label their wafers for herbivores and omnivores. That's another reason to feed at night, when your pleco has a better chance of getting its share.
Do I need to remove uneaten wafers?
Yes. Every maker on this page says to remove uneaten food. Leftovers break down into ammonia, so if you're seeing high readings, read how to lower ammonia in a fish tank.
Choosing food for the rest of your tank? See how to choose fish food: flakes vs pellets vs wafers, or browse all fish food, Hikari, NorthFin and New Life Spectrum.