Best sand for a reef tank: live sand vs dry aragonite

Live sand or dry aragonite? Compare CaribSea reef sands by grain size, see how much sand you need and how to add it without clouding the tank.

Short answer: For most reef tanks, the best sand is a medium aragonite sand in the 1–2 mm range, such as CaribSea Arag-Alive Special Grade Reef (live) or CaribSea Special Grade Reef Sand (dry). Choose live sand if you want a bag that is ready to pour in with no rinsing and comes packed with beneficial bacteria to help start your cycle. Choose dry sand if you are happy to rinse it first and let bacteria from your rock, filter or a bottled starter colonize it over time. If you keep sand-sifting gobies, wrasses or jawfish, look at a fine oolitic sand like Arag-Alive Bahamas Oolite.

Why reef tanks use aragonite sand

Almost every reef sand is aragonite, a calcium carbonate mineral. Aragonite sands help buffer pH and alkalinity, which is why they belong in saltwater tanks. CaribSea notes that its Arag-Alive sands raise pH and alkalinity and should only be used in marine, reef or African cichlid aquariums, not in a regular freshwater tank. CaribSea also says its aragonite substrates are engineered to be free of impurities such as ash, metals, pesticides and silica.

So the real decisions are: live or dry, and which grain size.

Live sand vs dry sand: what's the difference?

Live sand is packed wet. CaribSea says its Arag-Alive sands are ready to work, clear quickly and contain millions of live bacteria to help a new tank cycle and reach a natural biological balance. CaribSea's Bio-Magnet Clarifier is now mixed into the packing liquid, so there is no separate packet to find. You do not rinse Arag-Alive; you open the bag and pour the contents into the tank.

CaribSea Ocean Direct is a different kind of live sand. CaribSea says it is real live sand preserved with its own original bacteria in a breathable bag, with every grain coated in a thin film of real ocean water.

Dry sand is exactly that: dry aragonite with no living bacteria in the bag. CaribSea recommends rinsing dry sand before use to remove dust. It becomes "live" once it is in your running tank and bacteria from your rock, filter media or a bacteria product move in. If you are starting with dry rock as well, read our guide to cycling a new tank and our comparison of dry rock vs live rock.

Reef sand compared by grain size

Grain size is the biggest practical difference between reef sands. These are CaribSea's published typical grain sizes for the sands we carry:

Sand Live or dry Typical grain size (CaribSea) Good fit for
Arag-Alive Special Grade Reef Live 1.0–2.0 mm Most reef tanks; a versatile all-rounder
Special Grade Reef Sand Dry 1.0–2.0 mm The same versatile grain, dry, in bigger bags
Arag-Alive Fiji Pink Live 0.5–1.5 mm A finer sand with natural pink tones
Fiji Pink Aragonite Sand Dry 0.5–1.5 mm Fiji Pink look, dry, for reef or fish-only systems
Arag-Alive Bahamas Oolite Live 0.25–1.0 mm Sand-sifting gobies, wrasses, jawfish and deep sand beds
Arag-Alive Hawaiian Black Live 0.25–3.5 mm A dramatic black bottom that makes fish and corals stand out
Arag-Alive Bimini Pink Live 0.5–5.0 mm Pink tones like Fiji Pink, with a coarser mixed grain
Arag-Alive Natural Reef Live 0.2–10.0 mm The widest grain mix here, for a natural reef-bottom look
Ocean Direct Original Grade Live 0.25–6.5 mm A natural mixed-grain live sand for new or established reefs

Browse every option, including crushed coral and freshwater sands, in our substrate collection.

Which reef sand should you buy?

  • Not sure? Start with Special Grade. Our listings describe this 1–2 mm grain as a versatile choice that suits most reef and marine aquariums. Pick Arag-Alive Special Grade for a no-rinse live start, or dry Special Grade if you prefer to rinse and seed it yourself.
  • Want a finer, softer look? Fiji Pink is a step finer at 0.5–1.5 mm and comes both live and dry.
  • Keeping sand sifters or burrowers? Bahamas Oolite is the finest grain here, and our listing recommends it for sand-sifting gobies, wrasses and jawfish.
  • Want something different? Hawaiian Black gives a black reef floor, Bimini Pink is a coarser pink live sand, Natural Reef mixes fine and coarse grains like a real reef bottom, and Ocean Direct Original Grade is a mixed-grain sand with its own natural ocean bacteria.

How much sand do you need?

CaribSea's general rule is 1 to 2 pounds of sand per gallon of tank. Our product listings plan on about 1 lb per gallon for a 1 inch sand bed.

For a more exact number, CaribSea gives this formula:

  1. Multiply tank length × width × the bed depth you want, all in inches.
  2. Divide by 1,728 to get cubic feet.
  3. Multiply by the sand's approximate density in pounds per cubic foot. CaribSea's FAQ lists about 100 for Arag-Alive and Ocean Direct sands, 85 for Special Grade Reef Sand and 90 for dry Fiji Pink and Special Grade Reef Sand.

For example, a 36 × 18 inch tank with a 1 inch bed is 648 cubic inches. 648 ÷ 1,728 = 0.375 cubic feet. Multiply by 90 for dry Fiji Pink and you need about 34 lb, so one 40 lb bag.

How to add reef sand without clouding the tank

Live sand (Arag-Alive): no rinsing. CaribSea says to put the sand in first, before the tank water, because pouring sand through the water column causes unnecessary cloudiness. Our listings suggest adding the bag's water and sand gently, ideally before filling or with the tank drained low, and letting the cloud settle with filtration running.

Dry sand: rinse first. CaribSea's method is to put a few pounds at a time in a clean bucket and rinse until the water goes from milky to just cloudy. A faster way is to cut the upper corners off the bag, run a hose into one corner and let the dusty water run out the other, moving the hose around. Then add the sand to the empty tank and fill slowly over a plate or bag.

Then: add your rock and décor, start all pumps and filters, and give it time. CaribSea says a tank should begin to clear within hours and be completely clear in 24 to 48 hours, depending on the product. If it stays hazy, see how to clear cloudy aquarium water.

Adding livestock and adding more sand later

Go slowly. Once the tank has cleared, CaribSea suggests no more than 1 inch of fish per 20 gallons for the first two weeks, then no more than 1 inch of fish per 5 gallons in total. Invertebrates can go in once you can see the back of the tank, with the same restraint.

To top up an existing sand bed, CaribSea recommends mixing in about a cup of sand per day. Do not cap an old bed with a layer of new sand, because that can cause another cycle. To replace sand, siphon and replace only about 5 to 10% of the bed per week, starting at one side, and do extra water changes for the next 4 to 6 weeks.

What you need for a new reef sand bed

Shop all reef sands in our substrate collection, or browse everything for marine tanks in saltwater.